Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Does accepting a settlement offer on a closed credit card account help or hurt you in the long run. Account closed with Best Buy in December and now receiving settlement offers from CRA. Should you go for it? What about requesting a pay for delete along with it? 

Link to post
Share on other sites

On 6/16/2020 at 6:39 AM, KKP said:

Does accepting a settlement offer on a closed credit card account help or hurt you in the long run. Account closed with Best Buy in December and now receiving settlement offers from CRA. Should you go for it? What about requesting a pay for delete along with it? 

define "hurt you in the long run"

 

If you mean in terms of credit scores... settling is terrible especially if you re doing it with a CA and not the OC.

 

PFD is unlikely on a within SOL debt.

 

what are you trying to accomplish?

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 3 weeks later...
10 hours ago, KKP said:

My goal is to get the account removed. Its a closed credit card account with Best Buy. 

if you settle without a PFD then it will report for about 7 years from the DOFD as a major derogatory item on your four consumer credit reports.

 

Is it out of SOL for your state and this type of debt?

Link to post
Share on other sites

From my personal experience dealing with collection agencies and getting the lowest possible settlement offer was low balling the agent that I had one the phone. These collection agencies buy your debt for literally pennies on the dollar, so whatever they collect from you is pure profit. I had two cars repossessed when I was younger, the total amount owed was $28,000, I settled for $4200 a few years later when I had enough money to clean my credit. Its all about your negotiation skills, or you can hire an agency do this for you if you are not comfortable doing it yourself. Have you started negotiations yet?

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Admin
11 hours ago, Debtblogger said:

From my personal experience dealing with collection agencies and getting the lowest possible settlement offer was low balling the agent that I had one the phone. These collection agencies buy your debt for literally pennies on the dollar, so whatever they collect from you is pure profit. I had two cars repossessed when I was younger, the total amount owed was $28,000, I settled for $4200 a few years later when I had enough money to clean my credit. Its all about your negotiation skills, or you can hire an agency do this for you if you are not comfortable doing it yourself. Have you started negotiations yet?

This board does not endorse any CRO.

Link to post
Share on other sites
11 hours ago, Debtblogger said:

These collection agencies buy your debt for literally pennies on the dollar, so whatever they collect from you is pure profit.

This statement doesn't account for all of the debts that are purchased for "pennies on the dollar" that go uncollected...

 

...or any of the overhead costs associated with leasing office space, carrying insurance, paying for phone and data lines, employee salaries and benefits, taxes, janitorial services, legal services, utilities, leases on office equipment and furniture, or those individual packets of ground coffee for the break room.

 

[No portion of this post should be construed as advocacy for the collection industry, or as a suggestion that deadbeat consumers should be ground into burger patties and served in high school cafeterias.]

Link to post
Share on other sites
16 hours ago, Debtblogger said:

From my personal experience dealing with collection agencies and getting the lowest possible settlement offer was low balling the agent that I had one the phone. These collection agencies buy your debt for literally pennies on the dollar, so whatever they collect from you is pure profit. I had two cars repossessed when I was younger, the total amount owed was $28,000, I settled for $4200 a few years later when I had enough money to clean my credit. Its all about your negotiation skills, or you can hire an agency do this for you if you are not comfortable doing it yourself. Have you started negotiations yet?

The 'pennies on a dollar' thing is NOT an accurate statement.  It becomes a bit closer when you get to tertiary (or subsequent) sales, but the initial purchaser NOW is getting most paperwork and while the paper is still well within the window to litigate.  THOSE sales are NOT pennies on the dollar.  Further, you falsely presume that ALL entities seeking to collect that are NOT the OC are purchasers as opposed to entities who are working on contingency (because the OC still OWNS the paper). 

 

I WOULD agree with the premise that negotiation skills are an essential piece of the equation...one lacked even by many who claim to be 'skilled' in the arena. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Similar Content

    • By NewlySeperate
      I’m newly separated and I’m trying to re-establish my credit and financial independence.  There are 4 collections on my credit report that my husband was responsible for when we were together in 2020.  We both had extensive blood work done by a lab of which he was paying. We separated and he has not been paying so it went to collections and showed up on my report. 
       
      I just disputed them online a few days ago and am waiting to see if they are removed. It has my name and not his. Is it even conceivable they will be deleted?  My score is in the 500 range right now. I don’t have much credit but want to repair and build.
    • By BigSpenderBigSaver
      Hello all. The title says just about everything. Is it known whether or not AMEX holds closed accounts against you when opening new ones?
       
      I had three (3) AMEX accounts, none of them were Gold. I entered all three in a DMP (I wanted to keep one open, but the DMP told me not to or else lenders may not accept the plan). I just paid off all three well ahead of the end of the DMP end date. To my knowledge, I have not be subject to an F/R.
       
      FICO scores as follows:
      EX 713
      TU 717
      EQ 701
       
      I was approved for the CSP yesterday (7/23/21) so I will have a new account lowering my AAoA. I not looking to apply for the AMEX Gold for a few months (depending on your feedback).
       
      Thanks!
       
       
      Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
    • By condemnity
      Hi All,
       
       
      I'm trying to understand the best approach on good will letters for two cards that I settled a few years ago and finished paying in 2020.
       
      I had a Bank of America card and Amex which were both charged off after working with a debt settlement company. I was then sued by both cards and BoA garnished my bank account.
       
      After hiring a lawyer, the accounts got settled and I finished paying last year. However, the law firm I hired didn’t secure any guarantee to remove the cards from my credit report after payment.
       
      I'm starting to look for car leases through Honda and want to improve my scores to get the best rate/amount before I apply so I’m trying to figure out how to handle those two accounts in particular.
       
      My FICO scores are currently - Ex: 646; Eq: 657; TU: 617.
       
      The issues are:
      * Serious delinquency
      * Few accounts paid on time
      * No loan activity
      * Bad payment history
       
      I've done a few things to start counteracting the effects, including:
      * Opening a credit card account with Amex (1k limit) in November of last year, not using it too much and paying it in full each month.
      * Opening a Capital One card (2k limit) in April, using it more frequently for every day purchases and paying full balances every few weeks.
      * Opening a credit builder loan this month to establish a consistent payment history.
      * Asking  my girlfriend who has excellent credit and a long credit history to put me on as a registered user.
       
      I think these are good steps to take, but the obvious big issue is the serious delinquency, so I'm trying to get the credit cards removed from my CR. 
       
      I've disputed the cards to try to have them removed from all three CRAs and they both came back as verified, so that didn’t work.
       
      My next step is going to be a good will letter to both creditors.
       
      I'm mainly planning on highlighting the circumstances (divorce, undisciplined spending, etc) that caused me to default. 
       
      I then want to highlight with Amex that I have a new card with them and have been very responsible over the course of the last few months. For both cards, I want to highlight all of the progress I've made in my financial life, learning to budget and to be disciplined about financial management, my changed views on credit, etc. 
       
      My hope is that they will remove the accounts from my CR and that will highlight my positive payment history on past loans, etc. 
       
       
      My main question for the group is, do you see any issues with my approach (mainly with regards to the goodwill letter, but generally is also welcome)? 
       
      Should I try to remove individual payments instead of trying to remove the entire cards?
       
      I did have a positive payment history with each card at some point, so I feel this could be a more useful approach, but it seems a lot more work for whoever reads the letter vs just deleting the account completely. 
       
      Any other advice on what to include? Would it be crazy to include budgets, net worth statements, etc to prove that I’m on the up and up?
       
      Thanks in advance!
    • By CandiedCredit
      Hi Everyone, I have been at war with the big 3 for a few months now. I have had success with equifax and Transunion removing old addresses. However Experian just will not budge. Ive tried letters and calling and have gotten no where. My question is: Is it possible to dispute baddies off Equifax and Transunion, and once they remove items, to send some sort of follow suit letters to experian to get them to comply if the other two did? This is all hypothetical of course. I have not started disputing yet. Any advice would be greatly appreciated. 
    • By c0moneyman
      Wassup y’all, I went through a rough patch in my life when I was 18 and overcharged the freak out of a kohls charge card and it went into collections. I paid it off and now i’m thinking🤔, how can i get that removed off my report since i paid it off. I know i should’ve tried to write a letter to them saying if i pay it off they’ll knock it off my credit but i wasn’t thinking back then. Is it to late to contact them and ask to get it removed if possible? Im not tryna wait 7 years i’m trying to get a house next year y’all.



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      182,033
    • Most Online
      2,046

    Newest Member
    yeezeetaughtme
    Joined
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Guidelines