Jump to content

Please consider disabling your adblocker for CreditBoards if you have not already done so.  This site depends on advertising revenue to stay online.


Sign in to follow this  

JDB responds to validation with Application from OC

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

1. EX & EQ deleted a collection acct from my report in 2016 after one initial dispute 
2. In 2019, a JDB reports on EX & EQ for the same acct. I requested a DV and the JDB sent the initial application.

3. OC sent the wrong item in 2014 and after 6 months of disputing they stopping collection attempts. (technically this should be #1). 
4. I disputed the JDB (2nd ÇA) with the CRA’s and it came back verified. 

What letter can I send to the JDB after they responded with the initial application from 2014 and what is another dispute tactic to the CRA that only responds with previously verified. 
 

i searched but searching here is not the same anymore. 
thanks in a d’avance for input 

Edited by pissarita
Title clarify

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There is no absolute standard as to what qualifies as "validation" other than to address whether it would satisfy a court of competent jurisdiction that the correct party was being dunned and that the amount sought was consistent with the delinquency.

 

Kitchen sink letters are trash but a SPECIFIC dispute may very well be something that the original application would suffice.  Without knowing WHAT was placed into material dispute and WHAT State laws may exist in your jurisdiction, it is difficult to say what the next step would be...what you do NOT want to do is send generic tripe.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The FDCPA requires that they give you the name of the entity suing, the amount, and if requested, the original creditor. (usually only a JDB does that) Giving you the app tells you who the OC was. It's a pretty low standard. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, legaleagle2012 said:

The FDCPA requires that they give you the name of the entity suing, the amount, and if requested, the original creditor. (usually only a JDB does that) Giving you the app tells you who the OC was. It's a pretty low standard. 

And in some cases, this low bar is not hurdled.  

 

What usually happens is there is a mixup somewhere, and the wrong information is sent.  If that happens, and they continue to collect, that is a violation.

 

These situations are a lot more rare than they were in the old days.  I had over $100k in unsecured debt when the Great Recession started.  Tens of thousands of that were wiped out using the then-controversial TrueQ Arbitration method, which is now recommended by the same people who trashed TrueQ and his method back in the day.  But MOST of that debt was actually wiped out because of no validation.  I had between $60-70k of debt in two accounts with BOA.  I played a game of whack-a-mole for several years -- they would send an account to a CA, I would send a DV letter, and then no reply.  A few month later, a different CA would send info on the same account.  Finally they gave up.

 

There was another account with a different bank in which I sent a DV letter to a CA.  The CA asked the OC for validation, and the OC sent back a letter, which the CA forwarded, saying the OC didn't have to validate a debt.  The ID-10-T for the OC seriously didn't realize that they were precluding the CA from pursuing the debt.  I walked away from that one as well.

 

These situations are MUCH rarer than they used to be.  But occasionally this actually still happens.

 

If this actually happened, and they are contusing to collect the debt, then they are violating the FDCPA, and POSSIBLY the FCRA.

 

As others have mentioned, the bar is VERY low.  If they simply say: "we own the account, which we got from Big Bank, and the amount is $xxxx", they have cleared the hurdle and there is no violation.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Actually, they were required to send you any documentation.   Finding an entry on a credit report is not an initial communication that triggers a consumer’s right to demand validation under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act.  In addition, the Fair Credit Reporting Act does not require documentation be sent to a consumer in response to a dispute.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Bluesie58 said:

Actually, they were required to send you any documentation.   Finding an entry on a credit report is not an initial communication that triggers a consumer’s right to demand validation under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act.  In addition, the Fair Credit Reporting Act does not require documentation be sent to a consumer in response to a dispute.  

Hence my additional comment of needing to know what STATE laws apply...some (such as here in the Great State of Texas) are far better than federal statutes.  Others are just as ineffectual as federal law...

 

But, since OP has not come back to the thread, it is all meaningless...it is so frustrating to try and offer guidance only to have an OP never come back to the thread.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 5/8/2020 at 11:19 AM, centex said:

Hence my additional comment of needing to know what STATE laws apply...some (such as here in the Great State of Texas) are far better than federal statutes.  Others are just as ineffectual as federal law...

 

But, since OP has not come back to the thread, it is all meaningless...it is so frustrating to try and offer guidance only to have an OP never come back to the thread.

I’m here— what guidance do you have to offer please. I didn’t get a notice of response so my bad on the delay. 
 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, pissarita said:

I’m here— what guidance do you have to offer please. I didn’t get a notice of response so my bad on the delay.

See my reply from May 7th.  That additional information is needed to give any modicum of guidance that may actually apply to YOUR situation...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 5/7/2020 at 11:15 AM, centex said:

There is no absolute standard as to what qualifies as "validation" other than to address whether it would satisfy a court of competent jurisdiction that the correct party was being dunned and that the amount sought was consistent with the delinquency.

 

Kitchen sink letters are trash but a SPECIFIC dispute may very well be something that the original application would suffice.  Without knowing WHAT was placed into material dispute and WHAT State laws may exist in your jurisdiction, it is difficult to say what the next step would be...what you do NOT want to do is send generic tripe.

State GA. What do you mean ‘what was placed in material dispute’ ?

i disputed the validity of the account, the amount, contract obligations between JDB & me. 
History: The actual purchase was disputed with the original seller since they delivered the wrong item and their delivery service refused to carry it back to their truck and take their item with them!!! 
It went to some collection company and was deleted... now 5 yrs later it’s showing up from this JDB at 4x the cost. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It appears you did not pay for the item, nor did you send the wrong item back. That may pose a problem if this gets in front of a judge.  We need a lot more info than this. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, legaleagle2012 said:

It appears you did not pay for the item, nor did you send the wrong item back. That may pose a problem if this gets in front of a judge.  We need a lot more info than this. 

Interesting there was a 10% balance left  not including the shipping fees... arrangements were made for pick but they never showed. So to show a judge how they failed to pick up their product after numerous written communication of them agreeing to it— I might be ok. But who knows. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Similar Content

    • By ON-MY_way
      I had a NFCU cc of $25,xxx (25k) charged off in Dec. 2018.   During my small business startup and struggles I tried my best to stay afloat.  I managed to keep my  NFCU auto loan ($31k, balance $5,000, never miss/late payment) and NFCU cc ( $3000 never miss/late payment) current.  
       
      My Equifax lists:
      12/2018 Charged off account
      Date of Last Payment Aug 01, 2020 (I made NO PAYMENTS or arrangements since CO.  I keep little money (under $100 in my checking savings.  Low and behold In August 2020 I see a 'DR Adjustment' of $1000 from my checking.  After investigating I learned that a commercial account deposit I had in 2016 was credited back to me and the acct they had on file was NFCU and they snatched the grand and sent me a letter 'thanking me' for my payment of $1000.  
      My state is NC, does this now effect my SOL?   Is this legal for NFCU to take money from your checking account and update the CRA as you've made a payment when I did not initiate it?
       
      After this eye-opening moment, I did some research and it's my guess that NFCU loan terms have 'cross-collateralization' verbiage.  
      When my NFCU auto loan is paid in full, will they send me the title or 'hold' it until the CO is paid off or settled for agreed amount?  If I settle at a percentage of CO before auto loan is paid, will I get the title once auto loan is zero balance?
       
      I reached out to NFCU collections and got an offer to settle the co acct for $4000, so including the $1000 they already debited, that 20% of the charged off amount to stop the collection process.  I'm assuming even with all the lawsuits NFCU has been a part of since 2016 to present, PFD is not an option on the table as a counter offer.  I have the means to pay $4,000 to them within 10 days, besides my CRA showing 'paid, settled for less', how will this effect my credit and score?

      I know the general opinion on CB is that NFCU is GREAT and one should try to stay in their good graces, but it seems things there have changed for the downhill since 2017 and with a recent whistleblower lawsuit concerning their mortgage underwriting practices... their home loans advantage could also suffer in the near future.  Personally at this stage, I'm not '$25k-in-love' with NFCU, but if you can offer reasons to sway my judgment, it will be enlightening.   
      All in all, I'm seeking advice to get my title once the vehicle is paid off and maintaining the 'most amicable' relationship with NFCU going forward holding a single credit card, checking, and saving accts.  
       
    • By PS2020
      Heya, found this forum through a Reddit recommendation and have been thumbing through it for the past few days, and wanted to thank you all for the information you all post! I'm still kind of new to this, so I'm trying to best figure out how to handle my situation and could use some advice.
       
      The wife and I are thinking of home ownership in the next year or two so i'm trying to fix my side of the credit now. I THOUGHT I had several things in collections (frankly I should), but according to my credit reports from the big 3, I don't. Hell, I had 7 negative accounts back in january, but I checked again with annual credit report and I currently just have 3 accounts with negative marks. There's a 4th card that Experian and TU report, which is my Discount Tire (SYNCB/CAR CARE DISC TIRE), BUT it reports it as lost/stolen for some reason, even though I never did such a thing. REGARDLESS, I'll deal with that one if and when I need to (unless you have advice you'd like to give on that). I want to focus on the 3 that show up on all 3 credit reports.
       
      I'm not sure which Credit Report to go with as far as figuring out dates and stuff, because they're all kind of slightly different, so I'll mainly go with Experian:
       
      Amex -
      Payment Status - Charged Off
      Status Updated - September 2019
      Balance - $559
      Past Due Amount - $352
      Balance Updated - September 18 2020
      (Equifax) Delinquency First Reported - Sep 01, 2019
      (Trans Union) Estimated month and year that this item will be removed - 06/2022
       
      Chase Sapphire -
      Payment Status - Charged Off
      Status Updated - April 2019
      Balance - $5,693
      Past Due Amount - $5,693
      Balance Updated - April 22 2019
      (Equifax) Delinquency First Reported Apr 01, 2019
      (Trans Union) Estimated month and year that this item will be removed - 12/2020
       
      Chase Amazon -
      Payment Status - Charged Off
      Status Updated - April 2019
      Balance - $730
      Past Due Amount - $730
      Balance Updated - April 22 2019
      (Equifax) Delinquency First Reported Apr 01, 2019
      (Trans Union) Estimated month and year that this item will be removed - 09/2025
       
      I'm not sure why my sapphire says it'll be removed (allegedly of course) by the end of this year, because it's a higher debt and it wasn't paid the same time the chase amazon card wasn't, so that's where i'm confused. In fact, i'm just very confused in general, because I know I had more cards than this that I defaulted on unfortunately. I know you all heard every single "life was difficult" story, so please don't take my lack of elaborating as not caring about my mistakes, because I do deeply care; i'd just rather not bore you all with the same story you've heard before.
       
      SO
       
      I guess my question would be what is the best way of going about dealing with these 3 negative marks? I've gotten phone calls and letters for years and just never answer or respond to them. In fact, i'm sitting on a letter from Nationwide Credit in regards to my Chase Sapphire card from a couple weeks ago.
       
      Do I even bother dealing with letters from Nationwide Credit for example? Should I ignore those completely and go straight to the Original Creditors? If so, how do I even start that conversation? I'm in Illinois so I know the SOL is 5 years, which is why some of the "Estimated time this item will be removed" is confusing to me. 
       
      Anyways, thank you all for your time! If you need more info or if I asked in the wrong place, I'm deeply sorry! I just don't know where to start.
       
    • By Toast73
      Since my first store credit card in the summer of 1992 (JC Penney), Experian has used some form of subterfuge to decimate my credit rating with them.
       
      Their latest attempt to hornswoggle my credit report is actually frustrating me to the point of driving to their nearest corporate office (Schaumburg, IL).
       
      I have disputed items that are both obviously incorrect to the human eye and to the CRA. They verify the items and finish my dispute at 4:09AM.
      I request a reinvestigation. They verify it and finish the reinvestigation at 6:12AM.
       
      My report is in Special Handling, so I am confused as to why some pissed off Bangladeshi is completing my requests (as evidenced by the time of completion) instead of someone stateside.
       
      Nonetheless, I am overnighting 8 separate MOV letters to Experian requesting that they tell me who they spoke to at Montgomery Ward, and why an online catalog store told them I have an unsecured loan with them (when they do not offer such). Or how Gettington can tell me they cannot find anything they shipped to my non-existent address, yet can verify an account with Experian. (to name a few of my grievances).
       
      I am simultaneously sending each of the 8 companies a "Hey, can you tell me who you spoke with at Experian" letter. I fully expect all 8 to tell me "WTF are you talking about? Nobody from Experian contacted us."
       
      With paperwork in tow, I will find an FCRA attorney to hit them with 8 counts of FCRA malfeasance. I will look to settle with them for emotional damage, the violations, cost of preparing all notices (at $25 an hour) and whatever else is deemed just and proper.
       
      At this point, I'm not sure its about getting items removed anymore; it is painfully obvious that Experian (et al.) has a penchant for shoving the proverbial ham candle up the consumer's keister, sans lube, and intends to continue to do so with little (if any) oversight for all of eternity.
       
      I am still unsure if I can file action against LexisNexis for freezing my report in accordance with Georgia law (I am a Hoosier), and for referring to me as a female (my wife will verify my manparts if needed).
       
      Guess I am looking for input, and possibly some caveats, before firing these letters off.
    • By CCXX2018
      Hello,
      new to the forum (glad I found it) , I have a collection agency called Simon's agency which is trying to collect on an already paid debt , I have reported this to the CFPB but I need your advice on how to proceed further.
      Any help highly appreciated .
    • By Toast73
      So I disputed (or so I thought I disputed) addresses off the Big 4. TU removed all addresses except for my current. EQ has my current and another non-BK address. EX won't budge.
       
      All bureaus froze. Microbilt, LexisNexis, SageStream, Chex, you name it. 
       
      Try to get full verification of the bankruptcy on my file, thinking the whole Trial Rule 1005 thing would help me (this rule makes only the last 4 of your social, full name and addy public-facing).
       
      No dice.
       
      This was the response L/N fed me, including a few notes in RED.
       
      Please critique, tell me I have no chance for removal, something....
       
       



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      179,463
    • Most Online
      2,046

    Newest Member
    MrsOKW
    Joined

About Us

Since 2003, creditboards.com has helped thousands of people repair their credit, force abusive collection agents to follow the law, ensure proper reporting by credit reporting agencies, and provided financial education to help avoid the pitfalls that can lead to negative tradelines.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Guidelines