Jump to content

Any Thoughts Why Other CC Companies don't Backdate like AMEX


The last post in this topic was posted 2444 days ago. 

 

We strongly encourage you to start a new post instead of replying to this one.

Recommended Posts

I have been thinking about this since learning about Amex backdating and how it helps AAofA.

 

I have really two thoughts. One is I'm surprised that AMEX isn't pressured not to backdate new accounts since the rules say if you report (you don't have to report), you have to report accurately. I'm glad they do it, but they are kind of fudging there.

 

But what I really don't get is why some of their competitors don't do the same thing. That would be a huge benefit to members and would draw lots of new business and wouldn't cost a dime.

 

I am just surprised that AMEX seems to have a lock on this perk and is able to gain a competitive advantage over their peers.

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 117
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Technically,

 

it's *NOT* accurate reporting.

That was my point. Again, I'm very glad they do it (though I'm locked out), but if everyone dd it, the whole AAofA component of FICO would be meaningless. Just curious how they can do it and if they do it, why their competitors don't match it. Like I said, it's a benefit that has a zero dollar cost.

Edited by BJKill
Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorry if I shouldn't have asked. People seem to discuss a lot of potentially controversial things on here (i.e., b*) . I'm not sure where the line is in terms of asking questions. Not interested in upsetting the apple cart. Just trying to understand.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I have been thinking about this since learning about Amex backdating and how it helps AAofA.

 

I have really two thoughts. One is I'm surprised that AMEX isn't pressured not to backdate new accounts since the rules say if you report (you don't have to report), you have to report accurately. I'm glad they do it, but they are kind of fudging there.

 

But what I really don't get is why some of their competitors don't do the same thing. That would be a huge benefit to members and would draw lots of new business and wouldn't cost a dime.

 

I am just surprised that AMEX seems to have a lock on this perk and is able to gain a competitive advantage over their peers.

 

 

 

Amex D* is extremely widely known and talked about. It probably exists because Amex has always done it that way before CRAs existed in there present form while other, Johnny come latelys reported differently. Grandfathered in I suppose.

 

Given Amex's relatively high approval criteria existence of earlier accounts may not be a significant distortion. Now if First Premier D*.....

Edited by cashnocredit
Link to post
Share on other sites

 

Technically,

 

it's *NOT* accurate reporting.

That was my point. Again, I'm very glad they do it (though I'm locked out), but if everyone dd it, the whole AAofA component of FICO would be meaningless. Just curious how they can do it and if they do it, why their competitors don't match it. Like I said, it's a benefit that has a zero dollar cost.

 

You answered your own question, even before asking it ;)

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Admin

I think it's accurate in that it is a "member since" date, not an "issued" date. It's a nice little perk, but I don't think it's a big dissonance in reporting - I see it as how they "view" their customers. A fine point, but I think it's justifiable from the membership point of view. Like USAA's "once a member, always a member" - you can drop everything you have with USAA and come back years later - it's their idea of membership.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I think it's accurate in that it is a "member since" date, not an "issued" date. It's a nice little perk, but I don't think it's a big dissonance in reporting - I see it as how they "view" their customers. A fine point, but I think it's justifiable from the membership point of view. Like USAA's "once a member, always a member" - you can drop everything you have with USAA and come back years later - it's their idea of membership.

I agree.

 

Every time I'm on the phone with Amex they thank me for being a customer since 1995... even though I wasn't actually carrying any of their cards for most of that time.

Edited by cv91915
Link to post
Share on other sites

 

The only really enforced rule in credit reporting is that it can't be negative and incorrect.

 

 

What other type of rule are you suggesting?

 

Edit: After I re-read this it didn't come off as sarcastic as I thought I was being. :lol:

Edited by funkiehouse
Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorry if I shouldn't have asked. People seem to discuss a lot of potentially controversial things on here (i.e., b*) . I'm not sure where the line is in terms of asking questions. Not interested in upsetting the apple cart. Just trying to understand.

Don't make them change your name to D*Kill. :P

 

Mine are all reporting accurately.

Edited by Tyra
Link to post
Share on other sites

Talk about it enough,

 

and it'll be killed

Uhm, did you see this? It's 142 pages long and dates from 2011, and started by some guy named Bob. Hope nobody snooped on these boards in the last four years. LOL.

 

The Master American Express AmEx BackDating Back Dating Thread
Link to post
Share on other sites

 

 

Talk about it enough,

 

and it'll be killed

Uhm, did you see this? It's 142 pages long and dates from 2011, and started by some guy named Bob. Hope nobody snooped on these boards in the last four years. LOL.

The Master American Express AmEx BackDating Back Dating Thread

Amex knows Bob quite well. ;)

Link to post
Share on other sites

 

Talk about it enough,

 

and it'll be killed

Uhm, did you see this? It's 142 pages long and dates from 2011, and started by some guy named Bob. Hope nobody snooped on these boards in the last four years. LOL.

 

The Master American Express AmEx BackDating Back Dating Thread

 

As a result he was then smote by AMEX (S*). Mess with D* and you're gonna get S*

Link to post
Share on other sites

The last post in this topic was posted 2444 days ago. 

 

We strongly encourage you to start a new post instead of replying to this one.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Similar Content

    • By funkiehouse
      AMEX Platinum Charge Card 100k MR points after $3k spend in 3 months
       
      AMEX Premier Rewards Gold 50k MR points after $1k spend in 3 months
       
      Apply through Cardmatch tool without initial hard pull to pre-qualify - must be opted in - may be targeted
       
      https://www.creditcards.com/cardmatch/?aid=e9b5845b&bid=5cf9de14a9f94cb0
       
      More about the deal: http://thepointsguy.com/2015/01/amex-platinum-100000-point-offer-back-targeted/
       
       
    • By MJPEREZ77
      Happy New Year's to all my fellow CBers:
       
      Hope everyone had a safe and happy holiday season. I had a quick question, I have read threads on D* and in everything I got a little confused. With regards to an AU card, IF the AU had their OWN AMEX in say 1993 would they be able to use that as a D* date if added on as an AU? I know that it is said AU D* is dead, however, I kinda got turned around in my readings, I think that it is dead with regards to the MAIN CC Acct Holder having D* and the AU trying to get the SAME D* that really wasn't theirs. I am assuming that if the AU had a potential D* of 1993, that AMEX would honor it regardless of the date on the new acct, am I completely off here?
       
       
      Also, if AMEX did allow it, what might the impact be on the AU's AAOA. would it truly effect it? Or since it's only an AU card does it factor differently?
       
       
      As always, thanks for all your help and guidance, I have some success stories to share as soon as I get caught up with school.
    • By BJKill
      This is an academic question for me since I burned AMEX in my BK 7. That said, are people gaming carefully managing their AAOA by periodically opening and closing AMEX cards? Since you get D* for each AMEX card (open or closed), wouldn't it make sense to have as many of these reporting as possible -- open or closed? Obviously you don't want to pay a bunch of fees, but couldn't you churn the no AF products?
       
      Maybe this has been addressed before but I have been thinking about it. If people open and close various CC accounts regularly to churn bonus miles, why not churn Amices to heavily impact your AAofA?
    • By Aahz
      Other than D* and "prestige" what advantages are there to an AMEX Charge card, when compared to top-tier Visas or MasterCards, that justify AMEX's Annual Fees?
       
    • By funkiehouse
      You can use this link to apply for the AMEX HHonors Surpass and get an extra 20k in points with no additional spend (still $3k in 3 months) until Feb 28, 2015. This may be a good option for those going to apply in Jan or for those doing the AMEX end of year experiment or if you just want to be safe and apply now to establish a 2014 date with AMEX. This card also gives you GOLD status for great upgrades and free Wifi, which can sometimes be $20/night.
       
      AF is the same as the 60k link on the main AMEX page ($75) and is also not waived the first year.
       
      https://www262.americanexpress.com/dapply/web/applycard/us/personal-card/api/hil/hilton-hhonors-surpass-card/hhsc-024?wt.mc_id=CMEM_BUfyV3B89yK-nY
       
      If you recently got this card with the 60k bonus, go on AMEX chat and ask for the extra 20k. Provide this link to them, if they need proof that the offer is out there. Usually <90 days from the time your account was opened.
       
      Good luck and happy applying!!
       
       




  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      182,473
    • Most Online
      2,046

    Newest Member
    lawnguy112
    Joined
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Guidelines