Jump to content

Please consider disabling your adblocker for CreditBoards if you have not already done so.  This site depends on advertising revenue to stay online.


Sign in to follow this  

Take Chase Freedom offer or go for Amex BCE?

The last post in this topic was posted 2655 days ago. 

 

We strongly encourage you to start a new post instead of replying to this one.

Recommended Posts

First post. Really enjoy reading the forum.

 

I made a lot of mistakes with my credit and it has finally been 7 years since my last mistake. I have 36k in student loans that have established enough credit to pick up some cards.

 

I started with a cap1 secured (200) in April and went for the pre approved platinum offer in May (1000). I also got an amazon store card (400 in May then CLI to 1900 this month). My first big score came with getting in with NFCU because of my brother's service and getting there signature cash rewards visa with 17k limit in June. It definitely felt great.

 

My Exp FICO was 735 in my acceptance letter from Navy. Nothing has changed besides their inquiry and new account. My util is 1%, all on Navy, rest have no balance reporting. My income is 60k.

 

My student loans age back from 2005 as the oldest account, with new consolidated loans turning 2 years old next month. My AAOA is 13 months because of all the new cards, plus a $500 secured loan I took out in April that I am paying off to establish credit and get in with my local CU. My Eq has an old BOA account started in 1999 reporting as closed by creditor. I payed it off after much duress in 2006. No negatives reporting, 100% on time payment history.

 

My goals are to get an auto loan in about 1 year then getting a mortgage in 4 to 5. I would love to get in with Amex at some point to take advantage of their backdating and bonus offers in between.

 

I am getting some targeted offers (none from amex yet) and the $200 plus 14 mo no interest on a chase freedom is the most tempting yet. I am leaning toward going for it, but I was wondering if I had any chance of getting an amex bce/bcp or costco card first.

 

I only have a few months of revolving history, which seems a little weak for an amex. I see people with similar scores on credit pulls getting bce, but they may be more established. Plus I have quite a few new accounts and 3 inquiries on exp, 4 on TU.

 

I don't travel, so the easier delta card is not very useful. I don't want a $100 AF or more on a charge card when I can get several hundred worth of rewards on a Chase Freedom or Amex BCE/BCP in a few months.

 

So here are my options: take Chase and garden for however long it takes to get Amex pre approvals, go for BCE/BCP or costco (or maybe both) then garden until I'm ready for a new car, or go on a spree and get amex and hope Chase still wants me. I'm concerned that the inquiry from a failed amex app may kill the deal with Chase. Also should I apply now or wait for the accounts to turn 2, or even garden for a while instead of getting anything else now?

 

I spend plenty of money at costco and grocery stores to make the amex a good deal. I also plan to use amazon for Christmas shopping, the Freedom 4Q 5% plus no interest would be nice as well.

 

Aside, of the 3 amex, are they similar requirements? I see higher scores for preferred approvals. We do enough grocery shopping to make it worth the AF, but I'd prefer a safer bet.

 

Thanks so much for any advice or similar stories and sorry for the lengthiness.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you know you'll use Costco and spend a lot on groceries, I'd get the BCP and Amex Costco. Plus you'll get the Amex backdating which is nice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I used to wait for pre-approvals, but I dont think its a good strategy anymore. If you want an AmEx, go for it. If they say no, wait six months and try again. You have the chase pre-approval so if your really worried about a denial app amex first.

 

Sent from my SGH-T759 using Tapatalk 2

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the replies. I know pre approvals aren't worth all that much. I am just still gun shy from the days when my credit was bad and my income was low and I got denied for everything.

 

I was just wondering if getting an amex with such short revolving was just a pipe dream or if I have a real shot. I like the idea of getting 2013 cards in the future when I'm getting closer to the total garden state of mortgage prep.

 

If I did go for the total spree of BCP costco and then Freedom, should I do it all in one shot or spread out the apps in some way?

 

Anyone know if the costco is easier (or harder) to get? Didn't know if having history with costco helped at all.

 

Thanks again.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Update: I finally decided that I would risk the possible denial and went for the BCP. APPROVED! Not sure of limit. I had trouble getting into the online account so I figure I'll just wait a week.


Thanks for the encouragement. I was just afraid of denial, but I finally convinced myself it was worth the risk.


I decided to wait on the Costco card since it would really only benefit me for the extra 2% on Costco gas, and I'd have to wait so long for the rewards $. Plus I got the $250 bonus plus zero interest for 14 mo. for the BCP, which more than offsets the AF.


I then immediately applied for the Chase Freedom and was also approved for 5k. There was a note that said to discuss the limit when I call to activate the card. Anyone have any luck getting CLI on activation w/o another hard pull?


Thanks again for everyone who keeps this site going. I've been lurking for a while and I have learned a lot.


My next steps are to garden for 6 months and then decide if going for a January backdated Amex is worth it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Congrats on 2 great approvals! :clapping: As long as you have a Costco membership, you can still use the BCP there. :good:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

I decided to wait on the Costco card since it would really only benefit me for the extra 2% on Costco gas, and I'd have to wait so long for the rewards $. Plus I got the $250 bonus plus zero interest for 14 mo. for the BCP, which more than offsets the AF.

 

 

You will get 3% on gas as long as you have a Costco membership with BCP.

 

Congrats on the approvals !!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

You will get 3% on gas as long as you have a Costco membership with BCP.

 

Oh. I was under the impression that the gas benefit on BCP or other non-Costco cards was limited to stand alone gas stations.

It would definitely be nice to get all the benefits on one card, since I don't eat out or travel much.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

You will get 3% on gas as long as you have a Costco membership with BCP.

Oh. I was under the impression that the gas benefit on BCP or other non-Costco cards was limited to stand alone gas stations.

It would definitely be nice to get all the benefits on one card, since I don't eat out or travel much.

Yeah BCP gas rewards are good at any stand alone station. BCP is probably the best card I've ever had! Don't sweat the annual fee either the 6% saving at the grocery store make it well worth the annual fee.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The last post in this topic was posted 2655 days ago. 

 

We strongly encourage you to start a new post instead of replying to this one.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Similar Content

    • By Quietman
      OMG! Can't believe it worked!
       
      DW applied for 3x CLI, from $9,400 to $28,200, instant approval!
       
      It was on her Amex Blue everyday card.
       
      Her FICO scores:
       
      Exp : 789
      TU : 798
      Eq : 806
       
      Card used lightly over last 61 days, PIF always. She wants to achieve credit pimp status in the next year!!
       
      Thank you fellow CB'ers for all the great advice! (special shout out to BobWang, Ubercat, mendlesshon, HoustonLynne, CV91915, SecretAgentWoman)
       

       
       
    • By dilligaf
      Trying to keep it short ...
       
      I have been away for a while. Came back this week to say hi in GD. Started reading around in CF and saw this thread:
      The Master Blacklist Black List Thread – Work In Progress, Help Needed
       
      Now, I haven't applied for an Amex since 2007. Back then, the CO was no longer on my reports. Only denied because of internal blacklist. Not sure when it actually CO'd.
       
      So, I thought WTH. I'll try. Applied for the Everyday card because it looked kind of cool.
       
      FACO on TU is 721. The rest are unknown.
       
      I do have quite a few other cards at this point with about $50k total in CLs ranging from $500 (Target) up to $25k (USAA).
       
      I was approved for $2k. Eh. Not great. But, I am back in. Don't know if that is good or bad yet.
       
      Then I start reading about D*. Hmmm. Better check that out. Click the chat button and ask if I can get my Member Since date set back to my original. Sure Mr. D. Let me look that up for you. Is **** correct? Yes sir, that sounds about right. New date shows online before we finish the chat.
       
      Boom, a brand new CL from 1998.
       
      Once again, thanks CB. You guys are awesome as usual
    • By YAK25
      Hi.
       
      Anyone ever had any luck offsetting an AMEX annual fee or getting some kind of a retention bonus? I recently called the main line with regard to an annual fee on my BCP, and both the CSR and a supervisor told me that there was nothing they could do or offer me, despite my suggestion that I was seriously considering cancelling or at least downgrading the card to the no-annual-fee version.
       
      Just wondering if I should try my luck again with a different CSR or if there is a different number that I should call that would be more successful. As always, any feedback and help is greatly appreciated. Thanks!
    • By mendelssohn
      There are usually a lot of questions about why to apply for new Amex cards in January, particularly this time of year. Below is a brief explanation.
       
      When you have an Amex log in, you have a "Member Since" date. For example, here is what mine looks like when I log in to my account.
       

       
      Once you have established a "Member Since" date, every new Amex you open will show as being opened in the MS year. For example, every Amex I open reports as being opened in 1992. A new Amex will report the month that it was opened with the MS date as the year.
       
      For example, let's assume a MS date of 2013 and two different scenarios for opening a second card.
       
      MS date 2013
      Amex 2 opened December 2014
      Amex 2 reports as opened December 2013
      reports as 1 year old
       
      MS date 2013
      Amex 2 opened January 2015
      Amex 2 reports as opened January 2013
      reports as 2 years old
       
      If you have a really young MS date, you can see why applying in January can help you boost your AAOA over time. Waiting 1 month in this example nets another year of account age.
       
      If you don't have an Amex, it is wise to get one before the year ends to lock in a MS date.
       
      If you have a young MS date, it is wise to wait until January to take advantage of the account age as much as possible.
       
       
       
    • By JonE
      Wanting to transfer my balance from Credit One to Chase Freedom (when it gets here and activated) and close out Credit One. They do offer 0% for 15 months on Balance transfers, but is it that easy to do?
       
       



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      179,447
    • Most Online
      2,046

    Newest Member
    worktogetoutofdebt
    Joined

About Us

Since 2003, creditboards.com has helped thousands of people repair their credit, force abusive collection agents to follow the law, ensure proper reporting by credit reporting agencies, and provided financial education to help avoid the pitfalls that can lead to negative tradelines.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Guidelines